Mikhail Shishkin: Взятие Измаила [The Taking of Izmail]


The latest addition to my website is Mikhail Shishkin‘s Взятие Измаила [The Taking of Izmail]. This is one of his earlier novels, not (yet?) translated into English but, in my view more enjoyable than his two novels that have been translated into English. The blurb on the back of the French edition (which I read) says that even the author seems to lose track of what is going on. This may well be true but is part of the fascination of this novel. Shishkin starts off with a lawyer who specialises in helping young women accused of killing their babies but then moves on to another story, and then another, and so on. Often we do not know who is the narrator or who s/he is narrating to. He uses variations of their names – initial, familiar first name, patronymic and surname – often in an arbitrary fashion, so that it is not always easy to tell whether they are the same or different people. As in his other two books, there is inevitably a male and female Sasha. Characters jump into stories, disappear and then reappear several stories later. Of course, for much of them, life is grim. We see the horrors of Russian prisons and Russian psychiatric treatment but also individual sufferings and problems. We learn about phrenology, Volapük and the Russian law making it a criminal offense not to assist someone in mortal danger. But what Shishkin does do – and, I think, better than in the other two novels – is tell stories about Russians, Russian life, Russian customs, Russian history and, for good measure, about Hyperides, the Greek orator. It is a pity that it has not been translated into English, though you can read it in French and Italian, and I would hope that it will eventually appear in English.

This Post Has 10 Comments

  1. Dwight

    Thanks for posting on this. I enjoyed the first two translations into English, but I completely understand preferring a clear story (even if you’re not sure who’s telling it). I hope this does get translated since my French isn’t what it used to be, and was never great to start with. Again, thanks.

    1. tmn

      I also hope it gets translated as I think it is very worthwhile but, as usual, I am not optimistic about UK/US publishers doing the right thing when it comes to translations.

  2. The Untranslated

    So, we seem to agree that it’s his best novel to date. Good to see that. His debut novel Larionov’s Reminiscences, which basically is a deadpan pastiche of the 19th century Russian novel is, in my opinion, his weakest effort.

    1. tmn

      Yes, we agree. I have no plans to read any of his other novels, not least because none has, as far as I can see, been translated into a language I can read.

  3. The Untranslated

    Actually, Larionov’s Reminiscences has been translated into Italian. It was published together with the novella Calligraphy Lesson in one volume as Lezione di calligrafia by Voland (a cool name for a publisher!)

    1. tmn

      Thanks for that info but I will still pass, I think.

  4. tanya

    Where can I buy or load it in Russian.Thanks

      1. tanya

        Thanks a lot . Could not find it before

Leave a Reply